PROFILING EXAMPLE Grading An example grading criteria with qualifying statement: 1 – Performs seldom or inappropriately 2 – Performs sometimes, or sometimes inappropriately 3 – Performs often or mainly appropriately 4 – Performs always and appropriately Definitions Technical: Tactical: Physical: Mental:
skill levels, technical ability, set piece and open play. tactical awareness of roles in attack and defence. position specific physical attributes and body type. behavioural traits relevant to the position.
Individual Profile E.g. Left lock – this is not exhaustive, but illustrates some of the points that could be used POSITION
POSITIONAL CRITERIA Technical
Tactical
Move to create space, out manoeuvre opponents in the lineout.
Contribute appropriately to achieve a wheel when required.
In attack understand his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
In defence be aware of his role within the teams defence strategy.( rucks / mauls) Relish the mental challenge of being part of a dominant scrum.
Left Lock
Mental
Physical
Catch with soft hands and sympathetic when delivering the ball . Drive the front row into engagement and maintain forward pressure
Be aggressive with use of arms and hands to claim the ball. maintain a powerful driving position in the scrum. explosive jumping ability from a standing start.
GRADE AGAINST COMMENT CRITERIA 2 Often taps uncontrollably putting 9 under pressure. Off the top delivery requires greater control. 3 Very strong in this area, sometimes loses focus on opposition ball in their 22m 2 Slow, cumbersome movement prevents beating his opponent. Always does this 4 High ability to receive and in & out of – footwork needs 3 developing to enable him to attack spaces. Stays out of rucks/ mauls far too often – usually behind 10 / 12 2
4
Excellent contribution to scrum Strong upper body enables to compete in the air, with upper body
4 4
2
Physically strong in this area – may move sides to 3 rather than 1 Physically strong, not dynamic or agile enough
POSITION
ASPECT
TACTICAL
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Struggles with catching on occasion but can accurately . Forward pressure is maintained in scrums due to low, strong body position
2
Strong tackler
3
Aware of role and reaction to each lineout
4
Wheeling in scrums is unintentional rather than tactical
2
Must understand when to wheel
In attack understand his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
3
Always works hard to be in the right place but can be selfish with the ball
In defence be aware of his role within the teams defence strategy.( rucks / mauls) Relish the mental challenge of being part of a dominant scrum.
3
Occasionally will a ruck that is lost, reducing numbers in defence
4
Excellent scrum
Can lapse in concentration, especially when fatigued
2
Maintain a powerful driving position in the scrum throughout.
4
He relies on his physical attributes when tired instead of making correct decisions Physically strong in this area
A strong and fast runner with agility
4
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Callum Lipp
TECHNICAL
Loosehead Prop
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
Can be one of the best ers on the team, but lacks concentration to do this for a full game. Very strong in this area, sometimes loses focus Makes every tackle but occasionally his body height isn’t low enough and relies on arm strength Quick speed off the line helps beat opponent.
contribution
to
Physically strong and dynamic, especially for front row
POSITION
ASPECT
TACTICAL
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Predominantly catches well but delivery often too hard.
2
Has a tendency to drop easy es but catch difficult one
Hooks and drives well, tendency to hook early
3
Very strong in this area
Lineout throw is straight and can be varied well
4
Same as above
Lineout throw not always timed correctly
2
Throws are very accurate but sometimes to early or late.
Consistently completes for other team’s ball in scrums
4
Always does this
In attack understand his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
3
Often effective in attack but sometimes finds himself in the wrong place to be effective
4
Aware of his role within the teams strategy.( rucks / mauls) Relish the mental challenge of being part of a dominant scrum.
Consistent in understanding when to ruck and when not to
4
Excellent contribution to scrum
Constantly thinking to the point of over thinking aspects of the game Stays strong in and looks to keep continuity
2
Can get confused when too much information is given to him to work with Physically strong in the upper body
Struggles to be effective for an entire game
3
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Josh Morrison
TECHNICAL
Hooker
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
4
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
Cardiovascular endurance must be improved
POSITION
ASPECT
TACTICAL
COMMENT
Sure handed es
short
2
Catches well but brings the ball to chest resulting in no further es
Forward pressure is maintained in scrums due to low, strong body position
3
Very strong in this area
Tackle technique never dominant Slow to react from lineouts
2
Often shrinks from tackles, cannot reach dynamic position
2
Struggles to react to lineout outcomes.
Not as tactically aware as 1 in scrums
2
Same as above
In attack understands his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
4
Always finds himself in the correct place, carries fewer times than 1
In defence, is aware of his role within the teams defence strategy.( rucks / mauls) Never allows emotion to alter his play
3
Works in to good positions but struggles to make the tackles
4
Consistently solid in performance regardless of the situation
Has strong resolve and motivation to play full games Struggles in open space
4
He relies on his physical attributes when tired instead of making correct decisions Lack physical attributes to thrive with agile or quick players
Paces himself throughout the game to compensate
3
MENTAL
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
PHYSICAL
Lucas Higham
TECHNICAL
Tighthead prop
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
for
1
ed in Scotland No. 132061
Must improve endurance
Cardiovascular
POSITION
ASPECT
TACTICAL
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Soft hands when catching however es lacking in power
2
Catches well but unnecessary es
Forward pressure is maintained in scrums due to low, strong body position
3
Quite strong in this area
Tackle technique strong other than in body height
3
Reacts from Lineouts well
3
Often allows attacker to make meters before being low enough to complete the tackle Knows where to be after completion of lineout regardless of outcome
Quite tactically aware of scrum
3
Same as above
In attack understand his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
4
Always finds himself in the correct place and understanding his role and roles of those around him
Calls forwards in to defencive positions, showing understanding of his defencive roles and others’ Can occasionally become over aroused causing performance drop off
4
Works in to good positions but struggles to make ever tackle
3
Usually uses emotion to his advantage
4
Enjoys the challenge of tough games Works well in the loose
His work rate increases in tougher contests Runs with strength as well as use of footwork to attack space
Very agile for a second row
4
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Adam McAuley
TECHNICAL
Second Row
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
forces
Footwork and fundamental movement very strong
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Reliable catching however es lacking in power
2
Catches well predominantly, but forces unnecessary es
Attacks well with good fundamental skills of catch and
3
Nimble runner with ability to catch and effectively
Scrum technique is strong but lacks explosive leg drive and reset
2
Developing in this area over time
First in tackle is a hand grab resulting in poor technique from this point Recognition of stolen lineout lacking
1
Tackle is also improving, however use of shoulder and body height still key work ons Knows where to be after completion of lineout when won by attacking team
Awareness of scrum tactics lacking
1
Still new to the game and learning tactical uses
Awareness of attack structure lacking, often finds himself playing a back role in open play attack
1
Acts as a stray forward in the backs when unable to work out where to be
His role in defence is simpler and easier to achieve
3
Plays with a level head throughout games
4
Often around the ruck to stop anything near the breakdown coming through Unphased by challenges and plays consistently
2
Does not work hard when struggling at set piece
Can shrink away from set piece when oppositions shows dominance in that area Works well in the loose
3
Runs threateningly as well as use of footwork to attack space
Very agile for a second row
4
Footwork and fundamental movement very strong
MENTAL
TACTICAL
PHYSICAL
Ross McAuley
TECHNICAL
Second Row
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
2
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Good distributer of the ball when required
3
Sure handed over short to medium distance
Powerful leg drive to assist front row push
3
Physically strong in this area
Tackle technique often dominant Reacts from Lineouts well
4
Makes ever tackle but body height can creep up Knows where to be after completion of lineout regardless of outcome
Works harder to push at scrum than to be aware of next phase
2
Often late to detach from scrum
In attack understand his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
4
Always finds himself in the correct place
Knows to work hard in and around the breakdown in defence
4
Plays with a level head throughout games
4
An effective defender around the breakdown, does not move as wide as he could in defence Unphased by challenges and plays consistently
Does not raise his game when under pressure in set piece Strong and tall player
2
Can shrink away when set piece struggle
4
Runs with strength and able to get arms free for offloads
Runs well evasively for a back row
3
Footwork still could improve, fundamental movement quite strong
MENTAL
TACTICAL
PHYSICAL
Sam Ingrim
TECHNICAL
Blindside Flanker
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Catches and es below average
2
Sure handed over short distance but struggles any further
Strong and stable scrummaging position
3
Good scrum technique although leg drive not as strong as other forwards
Low body position in tackles but allows attacker to push forward Reacts from Lineouts well
2
Tendency to tackle ively resulting in opposition player moving forwards Knows where to be after completion of lineout regardless of outcome
Struggles to move quickly off scrum
4
Often late to detach from scrum
Can be late reading and reacting to decisions in attack
2
Not fast enough to recognize cues from his own team or what the defence shows
Much the same as in attack, slow to react to an attacking team or positioning himself effectively in defence Can hide when games become tough
2
Same as above
1
Struggles to adapt to tough situations
Does not raise his game when under pressure in set piece Not as strong as 6
2
Can shrink away when set piece struggle
2
Smaller build and height for an average back row at this level
Technique in scrums helps compensate lacking physical attributes
3
Often pushed back at break down and scrum when not set
TACTICAL
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Callum Clark
TECHNICAL
Openside Flanker
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Ideal distributer of the ball for back row
4
Catches well and can make every
Powerful leg drive to assist second row push at scrum
4
Drives well technique
Tackle technique often dominant Reacts from Lineouts quickly
3
Makes ever tackle becomes fatigued Knows where to completion of lineout of outcome, and opposition
Aware of his role in scrum push as well as getting to the first breakdown
4
Pressures every opposition scrum and resulting phase
In attack understand his roles in open play as a ball carrier, player or decoy
3
Works hard in attack although can get lost, however works hard to compensate
Works well in defencive structure in a wider area than 6 Plays with a level head throughout games
4
An effective defender around the breakdown, and can tackle in open space when required Can become undisciplined when in a close game
3
Loves the challenge of a physical scrum Strong and tall player
Very agile for back row
4
TACTICAL
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Chris Simpson
TECHNICAL
Number 8
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
4
3
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
with
good
low
until he be after regardless pressures
Looks to lead others when times become tough at set piece Runs with strength and able to get arms free for offloads Fundamental movement strong, excellent footwork and agility
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Accurate es to first receiver from rucks and scrums
3
es well as a 9 and can catch and in open play when required
Works well in to recycle ball despite smaller frame
3
Drives well and low in to offload or present
Often transfers his weight backwards when approaching for a tackle Understand when to from lineout and when not to
2
Low tackle but can be pushed away or allow attacker to gain ground Shows understanding of lineout defence
Aware of his role in scrum as distributer or decoy / runner
4
Works to from scrum in attack or defence
Understands his roles in attack, can take charge when there is no 10
4
Works hard keep continuity in attack as well as maintaining rugby speed
In defence; is aware of his role within the teams defence strategy.( rucks / mauls) Plays with a level head throughout games but can be affected by pressure
4
Knows where to be in defence and can communicate to forwards where to be
2
Can struggle to make usual es when under pressure
Does not raise his game when under pressure Smaller player
2
Over delegates to 10 when games become difficult. Works hard to compensate for lack of physical skills with technique
Very agile, shows a good burst of acceleration and footwork when entering area
3
TACTICAL
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Lewis Wason
TECHNICAL
Scrum Half
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
4
2
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
Fundamental movement strong, as well as footwork and agility
POSITION
ASPECT
TACTICAL
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Catches with soft hand and delivers accurate es
4
Always catches and es effectively, although can drop more difficult es
Works well in to recycle ball despite smaller frame
3
Drives well and low in to offload or present
Tackle technique low with strong arm bind.
4
Use of different running lines evident for manipulating defence
4
Often changes attackers direction due to strong low tackle Can fix defenders or slide to find an opening or
Decision making with the ball usually results in find players capable of making ground
3
Usually plays what’s in front of him, can become robotic in some decisions without thinking
Understands his roles in attack, takes charge of the whole team
4
Works hard keep continuity and structure in attack
In defence, calls when to or leave rucks correctly to set up defencive structure or turnover Plays with a level head throughout games regardless of pressure
4
Understands where he needs to be as well as where teammates should be
4
Makes correct throughout games
Captains the team well and shows mental toughness
4
Smaller player but has tremendous technique
3
Keeps the team motivated and provides specific to teammates throughout Works hard to compensate for lack of physical skills
Agile and elusive in small spaces
4
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Drew Cruickshanks
TECHNICAL
Stand Off
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
decisions
Fundamental movement strong, as well as footwork and agility
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Catches with soft hand and predominantly delivers accurate es
3
Occasionally lacking in follow through
Very effective in area, particularly defensively
4
Often creates turnovers at tackle area
Tackle technique low with strong arm bind. Use of different running lines evident for manipulating defence
3
Low effective tackle but not always dominant Can fix defenders or slide to find an opening off the ball
Decision making with the ball usually results in finding players capable of making ground
3
Usually plays what’s in front of him, can become unsure of himself
Understands his roles in attack, takes charge of the whole team
4
Works hard keep continuity and structure in attack
In defence, calls when to or leave rucks correctly to set up defencive structure or turnover Plays with a level head throughout games regardless of pressure
3
Understands where he needs to be as well as where teammates should be
3
Makes good decisions throughout games until fatigue sets in
Shows mental toughness and takes charge when 10 not available Smaller player but has tremendous technique
4
Keeps the team motivated and provides specific to teammates throughout Constantly in low strong body positions in and around areas
Agile and elusive in small spaces
3
TACTICAL
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Kiendi SearleMbullu
TECHNICAL
Inside Centre
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
4
4
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
Fundamental movement strong, as well as footwork and agility
POSITION
ASPECT
TACTICAL MENTAL PHYSICAL
Max Stewart
TECHNICAL
Outside Centre
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Catches with soft hand and delivers accurate es
4
Always catches and es effectively, has accurate es over all ranges
Works hard in to win the collision and recycle ball
4
Evasive and strong in this area
Tackle technique low with strong arm bind.
4
Attacks gaps in defencive line to get behind them
4
Often changes attackers direction due to strong low tackle Constantly gets behind the defence in attack
Understands the importance of width in attack and defence
3
Forces teams to find a way to beat them as they can’t go around them
Understands his roles in attack, adds width to the field
4
Knows he has better success when running at defences after a few es and executes this well
Very aware of what is needed at the breakdown
4
Loves the challenge another strong centre
of
3
Reacts quickly to breakdown result in order to attack or defend accordingly Can get carried away but channels this emotion well in to his play
Can go quiet late on in games so struggles to multitask cognitively when fatigued
3
Accelerates quickly with strong level drive and maintains well at top speed
4
Agile and elusive in small and open spaces
4
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
Keeps the team motivated and provides specific to teammates until fatigue sets in Strong in this area
Fundamental movement strong, as well as footwork and mobility
POSITION
ASPECT
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Catches with soft hand and delivers accurate es but without strength
3
Follow through improvement would be beneficial but es are still accurate
Dominates but relies on physical strength over footwork
2
Evasive running lacking occasionally and results in forced offloads
Tackle technique also relies on grabbing and outmuscling opponent. Struggles to locate ing options outside of basic patterns
2
Does not miss a tackle but is never textbook or dominant
2
Does not look beyond the short despite the best tactical option being elsewhere on occasion
Does not come off the wing for work, has a tendency to stay wide no matter the situation
2
Has skills that would be useful in other areas than the 5m channel
Has an understanding of structure but not displayed in game
3
Knows the theory of play but does not help in areas where he can
Understands when to commit to a breakdown or to stay out, tendency to do the later Can drop in performance when decisions go against him
2
Occasionally will miss a chance for a turnover
2
Often moans and drops performance when the game is not going his way
Always switched on and plays with rugby speed, when the above is not the case Accelerates quickly with strong leg drive and maintains well at top speed
4
Keeps up with play we due to his knowledge of the game
4
Leg drive also evident in breakdowns, thanks to low body position
Struggles with change of direction particularly at full speed
2
Runs with pace and strength in a straight line but must improve coordination to change direction more fluently
TACTICAL
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
Christopher Spence
TECHNICAL
Left Wing
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Right Wing
Struggles to control es not completely accurate
2
es have a tendency to be labored or slow
Luka Morrison
Low centre of gravity when entering and works well on the ground to present
3
Evasive running and good skills for offload and presentation
Tackle technique is a low chop tackle that allows for instant competition at the tackle area Scans well in attack but does not always pick the correct option
4
Always tackles effectively and able to return to feet quickly for a chance to steal possession
3
Aware of where to attack but can force some es that are not the best option available
Is able to identify where to be to be most effective in attack
3
Runs good lines and attacks gaps in the defence
Plays well in the loose although does not always understand roles of others around him
3
Lacks in depth knowledge of team structure but plays well as an individual within it
Too eager to a lost ruck in defence Can become over aroused and tries too hard when the team is struggling
2
Needs to know when to attack the ball and when to reset
Loves the challenge of a strong opposition Accelerates quickly with strong leg drive and maintains well at top speed
4
Can try too hard against strong opposition, trying to aid the team
4
Powerful and elusive runner
Has excellent agility, balance and coordination
4
Body control and fundamental movement well above standard
TECHNICAL
ASPECT
TACTICAL
MENTAL
PHYSICAL
POSITION
COMMENT
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
POSITIONAL CRITERIA
GRADE AGAINST CRITERIA
Fullback
Sure handed to catch and
3
Struggles to make accurate es over wide distant
Brodie Young
High body height in to in attack results in continuity becoming difficult
2
Footwork in helps to compensate for poor body angle
Tackle technique is a low strong tackle with good leg drive although slightly delayed Aware of where to counter attack, due to space or gaps in line chase
3
A sure tackler that makes every tackle, can take significant time before opposition reaches the ground Does not look to in this situation as often as required
Never engages in kicking battles, always runs back kicks
2
This can sometimes be the wrong option
Links well with others in open play and an effective communicator of where to attack and defend
3
Can communicate well in of tactical information of both teams, needs to do this more often
Constantly tracks ball in defence to cover any break through
4
Mentally tough and level headed
4
Always well positioned, knows where others need to be but does not always communicate this Decisions made throughout the game never change no matter fatigue
Constantly cool under pressure either playing or in time off
4
Always strong in this area
Accelerates quickly with strong leg drive and maintains well at top speed
4
Strong player coupled with excellent fundamental movement
Is effective for full games at a high level
4
Tremendous endurance
TECHNICAL
ASPECT
MENTAL
TACTICAL
PHYSICAL
POSITION
3
ed in Scotland No. 132061
COMMENT